Odd-Even Experiment Did Little In Reducing Air Pollution In Delhi: IIT Study

The odd-even experiment in the national capital yielded little in terms of reducing air pollution or congestion on the city roads, initial findings of an IIT-Delhi study has found.

In fact, the preliminary report says that average speed of vehicles “decreased” by a small amount between 8 AM and 11 AM when the restrictions were in force across locations.

The licence-plate policy, which is set to make a comeback on April 15 in Delhi, managed to reduce car use by about 35 per cent and not “50 per cent”, the report prepared by Transportation Research and Injury Prevention Programme of IIT-Delhi observes.

It says the benefits of the programme on the day-time air quality were not immediately apparent in the ambient measurements, due to meteorological factors and suggests that at least 20 monitoring stations are required for a “reliable analysis” of its effectiveness.

The Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC) now has six such stations. The government, in its recent budget, has allocated money to build three more stations that monitor real-time air quality.

More importantly, it suggests that the decrease in emissions from cars may be “offset” by an increase in flow of other vehicles such as buses, three-wheelers and motorised two-wheelers.

“In the lightof the fact that increase in flow of buses, three wheelers and motorised two-wheelers seems to be of a similar magnitude as the decrease in car flow, the effect of decrease in PM 2.5 emissions by cars would be even less,” it notes.

Source: Odd-Even Experiment Did Little In Reducing Air Pollution In Delhi: IIT Study

Posted in Air Quality, Asia, India | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Sahara dust only ‘partly responsible’ for UK’s worst pollution event in 10 years 

Thin film of red dust enveloping parts of country for two weeks in 2014 came mostly from farms in mainland Europe and local emissions, study says

Britain’s most serious air pollution event in the past 10 years was only partly caused by “natural” dust blowing in from the Sahara desert and mostly came from farmers fertilising their fields and industrial emissions from mainland Europe, a scientific paper has concluded.

The event, which lasted nearly two weeks in March and April in 2014, raised pollution levels to the highest level across much of Britain and France and for a short while spread a thin film of red dust across some parts of south-east England.

Although Defra and the Met office had warned people to stay indoors as air pollution worsened, it was the Sahara dust which caught the public and media imagination and led to No 10 dismissing the air pollution as natural and suggesting it was beyond the control of government or industry.

Cameron did not go on his usual morning run because of the pollution and on 3 April, nearly a week after levels soared, he told BBC1’s Breakfast TV: “It is unpleasant, and you can feel it in the air. But it’s a naturally occurring weather phenomenon. It sounds extraordinary, Saharan dust, but that is what it is.”

The authors of the study say that chemical analysis of the minute particles of pollution in the air showed that the desert dust was only present for a short time near the end of the 10-day pollution episode.

“The spring 2014 PM [particulate matter] episode was widely perceived as being associated with an enhanced surface concentration of mineral dust from the Sahara. An implication is that this was, at least in part, a ‘natural’ event,” they said in the scientific journal Environmental Research Letters.

“A significant contribution of Saharan dust at surface level was restricted only to the latter part of the elevated PM period and to a relatively small geographic area in the southern part of the UK.”

They showed through modelling that the dust was present at substantial surface concentrations only in the southern UK. “Overall, the percentage of modelled Saharan dust in PM2.5 and PM10 is less than 20% for most of the UK,” said the paper.

The authors say that much of the pollution came from European farmers spreading ammonia-based fertiliser on their fields mixing with local pollution, from industry and traffic. Ammonia is a gas emitted from fertilisers and manure which condenses to form particles which can be blown long distances by the wind.

“The elevated PM during this period was mainly driven by ammonium nitrate, much of which was derived from emissions outside the UK. In the early part of the episode, Saharan dust remained aloft above the UK.”

The result, says the paper, was that the public was misinformed about air pollution. “The pollution episode in spring 2014 was widely attributed to Saharan dust in the UK media, thus placing a (false) emphasis on a natural phenomenon, which cannot be addressed by policy action.”

The authors added: “The focus on an ‘exciting headline’ may be attributable to the complexity of communicating atmospheric processes and the public observations of dust-fall on surfaces. There is a danger that important messages to high-level policy-makers may be obscured by attention-catching headlines.”

“The initial mischaracterisation of the PM event may also represent a missed opportunity to inform and educate the general public about the role of anthropogenic emissions, specifically agricultural emissions of ammonia, as a key contributor to many high PM pollution events in recent years,” they said.

Alan Andrews, a lawyer at the environment law firm ClientEarth which is mounting a legal challenge against the government’s air pollution cleanup plan, said: “This proves what many of us suspected at the time – politicians blamed the smog on Saharan dust when it was really caused by man-made pollution.

“By dismissing this as a natural phenomenon, the government was able to dodge taking any action. This is a betrayal of the thousands of people who are dying early each year in the UK from being forced to breathe dangerous levels of pollution.

“Instead of lobbying in Brussels for weaker pollution targets, our government should be working with our European neighbours to cut pollution across the continent and acting to reduce the home-grown pollution which chokes our towns and cities on a daily basis.”

The study comes as the UK government pushes to water-down new EU targets for ammonia emissions, having recently succeeded in halving its own proposed reduction target for 2030 from 24% to 11%.

Source: Sahara dust only ‘partly responsible’ for UK’s worst pollution event in 10 years | Environment | The Guardian

Posted in Air Quality, Europe, UK | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Respirator mask reduces effects of pollution on the heart

The use of a respiratory filter mask, a common practice in China and Japan, among other countries, helps minimize the impact of pollution on people with heart failure during rush-hour traffic in cities such as São Paulo, Brazil.

For healthy people, wearing this type of anti-pollution mask can also reduce the risk of developing cardiovascular disease.

These are the main findings of a study performed by researchers at the Heart Failure Center of the University of São Paulo’s Heart Institute (INCOR-USP), part of the general and teaching hospital run by the university’s medical school (HC-FMUSP).

“The study shows for the first time that it’s possible to intervene simply, cheaply and effectively in a situation of risk for patients with heart failure due to exposure to air pollution from motor vehicle traffic in cities. Intervention of this kind can have beneficial public health effects and can reduce mortality from cardiovascular diseases”, said principal investigator Edimar Alcides Bocchi, who heads the Heart Failure Center and is also a professor at the Medical School’s Department of Cardiopulmonary Sciences.

The air pollution caused by city traffic has recently begun to be considered a risk factor for coronary heart disease and adverse cardiovascular events such as stroke and acute myocardial infarction, according to Bocchi. The toxic particles expelled by motor vehicles easily penetrate the airways.

In the past, however, most studies of the subject focused on the effects of air pollution on patients already suffering from the aftermath of a heart attack or with diabetes and metabolic syndrome.

Hitherto, no studies had investigated patients with cardiovascular conditions such as heart failure, which is when the heart cannot pump enough blood to supply oxygen and nutrients to other organs. Heart failure causes 10.8% of deaths in Brazil and is the leading cause of hospitalization for the treatment of cardiorespiratory diseases via the Brazilian national health system (SUS).

To assess the effects of pollution on patients with heart failure, the researchers exposed 41 people to controlled pollution: 26 patients undergoing treatment at INCOR and 15 control volunteers with healthy hearts.

The study was performed in collaboration with the Pollution Experiment Laboratory at USP’s Medical School. The participants were exposed to three different levels of air quality, at rest for 15 minutes and while walking on a treadmill for six minutes at an easy but moderately tiring pace.

In the first session, they received clean air, which they breathed in through a mouthpiece from compressed air cylinders.

In the second session, they were exposed to unfiltered polluted air consisting of a mixture of clean air and exhaust gases from a diesel engine with 300 micrograms of particulate matter per cubic meter, equivalent to half the particulate matter in the air of São Paulo City during most of the year according to measurements by CETESB, the São Paulo State environmental agency.

In the third session, the participants breathed polluted air but were protected by a particulate respirator mask with a filter, such as the masks that are worn by health workers and sold in pharmacies.

The participants’ endothelial function and heart rate variability were measured for each session, as well as serum biomarkers such as B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP).

BNP is a hormone secreted by the ventricles and atria of the heart in response to excessive stretching or stressing of heart muscle cells, usually a sign of heart failure. The endothelium is a thin membrane that lines the inside of the heart and blood vessels. Endothelial cells release substances that control vascular relaxation and contraction as well as blood clotting.

The results of the experiment showed that exposure to polluted air caused an increase in BNP and deterioration in endothelial function, whereas use of the respirator mask caused a reduction in BNP and an improvement in endothelial function.

BNP rose significantly during the 21 minutes of exposure to polluted air, and when the patients wore the mask it fell back to the base rate measured while they breathed clean air.

According to the researchers, the results of the study suggest that wearing a respirator mask is especially beneficial for people with heart failure and who are repeatedly exposed to air pollution from motor vehicles, such as bus, truck and taxi drivers, traffic wardens, police, and filing station attendants.

In addition to these groups, however, wearing a mask can also benefit people without heart failure by protecting them against endothelial dysfunction, considered a risk factor for coronary heart disease.

Source: Respirator mask reduces effects of pollution on the heart

Posted in Air Quality, Health Effects of Air Pollution, Medical Studies | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Mexico City Doubles Driving Ban as Pollution Persists

Mexico City authorities have doubled down on the capital’s emergency driving ban, ordering two out of every five private vehicles to stay off the road Wednesday as heavy smog continued to blanket the megalopolis.

Mexico City has struggled since mid-March to contain high levels of ozone, which has risen well above maximum levels recommended by the World Health Organization, prompting the city to declare its first pollution emergencies in more than a decade. High levels of ozone contribute to respiratory problems such as asthma.

Cars are blamed for emitting 90% of the pollutants that led to the ozone buildup. The Environmental Commission for the Megalopolis estimates there are 10 million vehicles in the metropolitan area, where more than 20 million people reside. The area includes the Mexican capital and surrounding suburbs.

Officials had banned every car from hitting the road one weekday each week and one Saturday a month from April through June based on their license plate numbers and regardless of how new the vehicles are or how they fare on emissions tests.

But after an air-quality monitoring station in the city measured ozone at 160 micrograms per cubic meter on Tuesday—the WHO recommends 100 micrograms at most—the environmental commission issued an emergency order forcing twice as many cars to stay off the roads Wednesday.

Critics say that over time such driving restrictions encourage people to own two cars, increasing the number of vehicles in circulation.

Guillermo Rosales, head of the Mexican Automotive Distributors Association, called the broad ban a “perverse incentive” to keep cheap, obsolete and dirty cars in circulation. “We need incentives that favor the renovation and substitution of the vehicle fleet,” he said.

As part of the emergency measures, outdoor recreation is prohibited at schools, and residents with lung and heart disease are advised to stay indoors in the afternoon when ozone levels peak.

The Mexican Institute for Competitiveness, a think tank, estimates that each year in Mexico City 1,823 people die prematurely—before the age of 65—because of air pollution. Gabriela Alarcón, director of urban development at the institute, notes that plenty of residents have ignored advice against exercising outdoors on recent days of elevated pollution, despite widespread public awareness efforts.

Mexico City is prone to smog due to its unique geography. The city sits 7,350 feet above sea level, in a valley surrounded by mountains that can trap air and contaminants amid intense solar rays and high-pressure weather systems.

The metropolitan area is the heart of the country’s economic activity, accounting for more than a fifth of gross domestic product. The urban area has nearly quadrupled in size since 1980, but public transportation infrastructure hasn’t kept pace with that sprawl.

Government data show one of every three daily trips in the megalopolis is made by a private vehicle, while microtransit, such as rides on outdated and often belching shuttle buses, represents more than half of all trips.

Until last summer, Mexico City restricted daily use of vehicles that are more than eight years old. However, the Supreme Court ruled that restriction was discriminatory, arguing older cars should be allowed on the roads if they pass emissions tests. That decision paved the way for 1.8 million vehicles that could be used only a few days each week to potentially circulate all seven days.

Corruption at vehicle emissions-control centers meant owners could pay extra for a passing test. Just last year, authorities shut down 42 errant emissions-testing centers in the metropolitan area for violations.

Emissions controls, widely available credit, and a crackdown on imports of aging vehicles from the U.S. contributed to record new-car sales in Mexico last year, when consumers purchased 1.35 million vehicles, a fifth of those in and around Mexico City.

The newer the car, the better its technology and ability to curb emissions, car industry representatives argue.

“At the end of the day, we’re looking to improve the quality of the air and therefore of course the health of citizens of this megalopolis,” said Eduardo Solis, head of the Mexican Automotive Industry Association, which represents auto makers.

According to Mr. Solis, the average private vehicle in Mexico City is 14 years old, whereas heavy trucks and buses are usually more than 17 years old. In the U.S., the typical vehicle is 11 years old.

Mr. Solis suggested the government focus more on regulating heavy transport, such as forbidding delivery trucks from blocking lanes on busy roads during rush hour, and banning big rigs from traversing the capital during the day.

The Mexican trucking industry chamber, meanwhile, argued its members should be exempt from the ban to avoid bottlenecks in bringing supplies into the city.

The restrictions don’t apply to trucks carrying perishables, public transport, school buses, or electric and hybrid cars.

Source: Mexico City Doubles Driving Ban as Pollution Persists – WSJ

Posted in Air Quality, Latin America, Mexico | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Mexico City faces air pollution … again 

The Atmospheric Monitoring System (Simat) reported a continuous bad air quality over 15 municipalities in the State of Mexico and eight districts in Mexico City.

The agency reported that the municipalities of Ecatepec and Tlalnepantla present 114 Imeca points, meaning that they have the worst air quality in the State of Mexico.

They are followed by Coacalco, Cuautitlán Izcalli, Cuautitlán Melchor Ocampo, Tultepec, Tultitlán, Tonanitla, Nextlalpan, Teoloyucan, Jaltenco, Tepotzotlán, Chalco, Valle de Chalco e Ixtapaluca, with more than a 100 points.

In Mexico City, the districts of Tlalpan, Coyoacán, Xochimilco, Iztacalco, Benito Juárez, Venustiano Carranza, Tláhuac and Gustavo A. Madero face the worst atmospheric quality.

In the rest of the Valley of Mexico, the air quality is just slightly better.

Source: Mexico City faces air pollution … again | El Universal

Posted in Air Quality | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Hanoi under a polluted cloud 

Many Hanoians seem unaware of the high air pollution in their city despite the warnings of environmentalists and statistics from the US Embassy’s air quality monitoring station in Lang Ha Street that show the air quality index remaining at unhealthy levels (between 151–200 units) over the past week.

These levels mean that everyone may begin to experience negative health effects, and members of sensitive groups may start to experience more serious health effects.

“Air pollution in Hanoi – it’s a very worrying situation now,” said Hoang Duong Tung, deputy head of the Vietnam Environment Administration, who talked to Vietnam News on Friday afternoon.

Tung said that the nearly five million motorbikes and half a million cars, the many construction sites, and people in outlying districts burning crops were the main contributors to pollution. The administration has previously warned people in the city many times about air pollution, he said.

Nguyễn Thu Hương, 30, a staff member of a bank in Đống Đa District, said she had heard about the air pollution in Hanoi early last month via a TV news broadcast. She said at the time she was worried about it, but was too busy to give it prolonged thought.

Nguyen Anh Tai, 26, said the sky appeared smoky and foggy, but thought it was just bad weather.

Dozens of people who were randomly questioned by the Vietnam News about how much they cared about the air quality index in the city had similar answers to Huong and Tai.

Most of them had never accessed the websites http://vietnam.usembassy.gov/air_quality_monitor.html, http://www.cem.gov.vn or http://www.aqivn.org/vi to find information about air quality.

In the meantime, expatriates in Hanoi certainly do care about air pollution.

Stephen Broke-Smith shared photos on the largest expat forum in the capital – the Hanoi Massive Facebook group – showing the air quality index in Hanoi on March 13 stayed around 231. This is considered a “very unhealthy” level.

Sandro Manzon commented, “I know that it is hard to accept, but Hanoi is one of the most polluted developing cities on earth… The air quality index sometimes stays around 300 for weeks. Anything over 250 is considered seriously hazardous.”

A Vietnamese Facebooker, Nguyen Quan shared his confusion about the air quality index data released by http://www.aqivn.org/vi after checking the air quality data in Hanoi provided by the state-owned Centre for Environmental Monitoring at http://www.cem.gov.vn. That site indicated that the current air quality index was only 55 – a moderate acceptable level. However, some pollutants still pose a moderate health risk to a small number of people. For example, people who are unusually sensitive to ozone may experience respiratory symptoms.

Explaining the difference between the two sets of data, Tung said that the different locations where the AQI monitoring stations were installed were the main reason.

The US Embassy used a beta ray analyzer to measure the air quality index, whereas the centre used a light-scattering device, he said, adding that this might help explain the dissimilar data.

“Although it is not an unusual phenomena in the city, it is true that the air quality index in the city is very worrying,” he said.

Tung also said that the administration was drafting a plan to control air pollution by 2020, with a vision towards 2030, and would soon submit to the Government plans to fix the situation.

At this time, the administration has co-operated with the Ministry of Transport and the Ministry of Construction to implement measures to mitigate air pollution in the city, he said.

According to the World Health Organisation, air pollution is an important determinant of health. The WHO estimates that in 2012, around one in eight deaths could be attributed to air pollution, making it the largest environmental risk factor for ill health.

Medical experts said people should wear masks to reduce the effects of air pollution on their health, especially in the case of respiratory disease.

Source: Hanoi under a polluted cloud – News VietNamNet

Posted in Air Quality, Asia, Vietnam | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Unable to curb pollution crisis, Medellin bans outdoor activity

Medellin authorities have temporarily suspended outdoor activities in the city following extreme levels of pollution in recent weeks.

Amid the current crisis, Mayor Federico Gutierrez put restrictions in place in order to limit the effects of air pollution on the 3 million inhabitants of Colombia’s second biggest city.

“We have all have to be concerned,we have never had the levels of pollution as these days. I am acting responsibly for the care and health of people,” Gutierrez told RCN Radio.

The mayor said he will not suspend classes in schools, but has asked educational institutions to not perform outdoor physical activities.

“We can not expose children to this environment, especially in the morning when there is more pollution. Children can go [to school] but remain in enclosed spaces,” added the mayor.

The authorities have introduced several other measures as the “City of the Eternal Spring” has gradually become the City of Eternal Smog.

The city’s metro can temporarily be used for free. Meanwhile a restriction has been put in place on the use of private cars and motorbikes as well as trucks for garbage collection.

According to a recent report by the World Health Organization (WHO), Medellin is one of the cities in Colombia with the highest concentration of pollutant particles such as dust, soot, ash, metal and cement.

This action by the Mayor temporarily aims at reducing the exposure of the public to these particles while as they continue to suffer the effects of the abnormal weather pattern caused by the “El Nino” phenomenon.

Source: Unable to curb pollution crisis, Medellin bans outdoor activity

Posted in Air Quality, Colombia, Latin America | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Extreme haze forces 77 schools to close for two days 

Seventy-seven schools in south-western Sabah are closed for two days after thick smoke enveloped the area amidst simmering peat fires from the Binsuluk Forest Reserve in the Klias peninsula.

Schools in Beaufort (53), Papar (10) and Kuala Penyu (14) were closed as the Air Pollutant Index (API) reached a very unhealthy reading of 279.

In some areas, the visibility was so bad that drivers could only see 20m ahead in the thick haze.

Sabah Education Department acting director Maimunah Suhaibul said the schools, involving over 20,000 students, would reopen tomorrow should conditions improve.

Although the Department of Environment (DOE) does not have a permanent station monitoring the air quality in Beaufort, the reading was taken off a portable machine.

Sabah DOE could not be reached and there were no updates on its website over the API and haze situa­tion.

“It is difficult to breathe. You can smell smoke the moment you walk out,” said housewife Rohani Rowel, 30.

Adding that she was keeping her children indoors, she said the situation deteriorated two days ago des­pite hazy conditions the past week.

Clerk Mazniah Mazta said visibility was sometimes less than 20m and that it was quite difficult to drive.

“The situation improved slightly but the haze came back. I think it is because of the winds,” she said, adding that like many people in Kuala Penyu, they were staying indoors.

As at press time, state Health Department director Christina Rundi had yet to issue any advice or statement if there was an increase in the number of respiratory cases in Beaufort and other parts of Sabah.

Firemen have been battling do­zens of jungle, bush and orchard fires on a daily basis as the dry spell – induced by El Nino – entered its third month in Sabah.

On Saturday, firemen said they had brought the Binsuluk forest peat fires under control after a series of aerial water bombings.

However, they warned that un­­der­growth fires could flare up from time to time.

Despite hazy conditions in Sabah’s west coast, including Kota Kinabalu and parts of Keningau, API readings there were at healthy levels.

Source: Extreme haze forces 77 schools to close for two days – Nation | The Star Online

Posted in Air Quality, Asia | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment